MX23RW : Sunday, September 22 02:01:06| >> :600:390480771:390480771:

Top five controversial referee decisions 2011-12

Top five controversial referee decisions 2011-12
© PA Photos
Sports Mole brings you the top five controversial decisions made by officials this season.

It is widely accepted that a referee and his assistants have one of the hardest jobs in football.

However, history is littered with occasions where the officials have made decisions that have baffled managers, players and supporters alike.

This season has been no different, with a number incidents causing controversy up and down the Premier League.

With that in mind, Sports Mole brings you the top five controversial decisions made by those with the whistles and the flag.

5. Dave Bryan - Not spotting Branislav Ivanovic was offside

Wigan Athletic, who were fighting relegation at the time, were putting up an admirable fight against Chelsea in April. However, all their hard work was undone when Branislav Ivanovic opened the scoring from close range. Having given the incident closer inspection, it would appear that assistant Dave Bryan had failed to spot that the Serbian defender was at least two yards offside when he converted the chance.


4. Martin Atkinson - Failing to send off Mario Balotelli

Quite simply, Balotelli could have ended the career of Arsenal midfielder Alex Song back in April. The Manchester City striker inserted his studs into Song's knee in full view of the watching world. However, Atkinson failed to spot the challenge, with the Italian escaping punishment altogether.


3. Andre Marriner - Allowing Morten Gamst Pedersen to dribble from a corner

Yet another selection for Wigan supporters to bemoan! Back in November Blackburn Rovers scored a goal against them when Junior Hoilett headed in a cross from Pedersen. What referee Marriner failed to spot was that after Yakubu had placed the ball in the corner quadrant, Pedersen simply dribbled the ball out before picking out Hoilett.


2. Martin Atkinson, Bob Pollock - Failing to award Clint Hill's 'ghost goal'

While many will sympathise with the officials over a lack of technology on this one, Hill's headed effort was a good yard over the line before Adam Bogdan cleared the ball out of his net. Pollock, who was running the line, was looking straight at the incident - which makes his failure to spot that the ball had crossed the line even more remarkable. If QPR were to be relegated by one goal this season, Messrs Atkinson and Pollock are likely to be off their Christmas card list.


1. Martin Atkinson - The Chelsea goal that never was

This incident completes a somewhat infamous hat-trick for Atkinson. In what was a crowded penalty area, the referee came to the verdict that Juan Mata's shot had cross Brad Friedel's line during Chelsea's FA Cup semi-final against Tottenham Hotspur. Replays showed that Atkinson had got the decision badly wrong as Chelsea went on to hit Spurs for five.

ID:26659: cacheID:26659:1false2false3false:QQ:: from db desktop :LenBod:restore:4460:
Restore Data
Share this article now:
Juan Mata
Read Next:
Juan Mata denies fatigue
>
rhs 2.0
Today's games header
6pm
Giants
@
Browns
6pm
Broncos
@
Buccaneers
6pm
Bears
@
Colts
6pm
Eagles
@
Saints
6pm
Chargers
@
Steelers
6pm
Packers
@
Titans
6pm
Texans
@
Vikings
9.05pm
Panthers
@
Raiders
9.05pm
Dolphins
@
Seahawks
9.25pm
Lions
@
Cardinals
9.25pm
Ravens
@
Cowboys
9.25pm
49ers
@
Rams
Tables header RHS
TeamPWDLFAGDPTS
1Liverpool5401101912
2Manchester CityMan City4400113812
3Aston Villa5401107312
4Chelsea5311115610
5Arsenal431061510
6Newcastle UnitedNewcastle531176110
7Brighton & Hove AlbionBrighton42206248
8Fulham52217528
9Nottingham ForestNott'm Forest42204228
10Tottenham HotspurSpurs52129547
11Manchester UnitedMan Utd52125507
12Brentford520379-26
13Bournemouth512258-35
14West Ham UnitedWest Ham511359-44
15Leicester CityLeicester503268-23
16Crystal Palace503247-33
17Ipswich TownIpswich503238-53
18Southampton501429-71
19Wolverhampton WanderersWolves5014514-91
20Everton5014514-91


Sports Mole provides in-depth previews and predictions for every match from the biggest leagues and competitions in world football.
Argentina's Lionel Messi kisses the World Cup trophy after collecting the Golden Ball award on December 18, 2022Sign up for our FREE daily preview newsletter direct to your inbox!